NEW YORK , April 7, 2022 /PRNewswire/ -- A panel of the National Advertising Review Board (NARB), the appellate advertising law body of BBB National Programs, has recommended that Bausch Health US, LLC discontinue or modify certain claims for its Bausch + Lomb INFUSE brand of silicone hydrogel daily contact lenses, including:
"Most Moisture" and "Lowest Modulus" claims;
"Maintains 96% of its moisture for a full 16 hours – more than the leading silicone hydrogel daily disposable";
Unsurpassed overall vision and comfort claim;
Vision, irritation, and dryness-related percentage agreement claims; and
The advertising at issue had been challenged before the National Advertising Division (NAD) by Alcon Vision, LLC, manufacturer of competing DAILIES TOTAL1 (DT1) contact lenses (Case No. 6951). After NAD's decision was rendered, Bausch + Lomb appealed to NARB as part of the advertising industry's self-regulatory process. The principal challenged claims, many of which are technical in nature and based on clinical testing of the products, had appeared in an INFUSE contact lens brochure distributed by Bausch+ Lomb to eye care professionals (ECPs).
"Most Moisture" and "Lowest Modulus" Claims
The NARB panel concluded that the evidence in the record shows that the advertiser and challenger use different technical approaches to try to minimize the disruption to homeostasis caused by wearing contact lenses. Referring to the INFUSE lens as monophasic and the DT1 lens as biphasic represent reasonably accurate descriptions of the technology.
In agreement with NAD, the panel recommended that Bausch + Lomb modify its "lowest modulus" and "most moisture" claims to clearly disclose the material distinction between the products (e.g., monophasic vs. biphasic) in a manner that is understandable to ECPs.
The NARB panel found that the focus of the Bausch + Lomb INFUSE brochure was to present Bausch + Lomb INFUSE lenses as a preferred option in terms of reducing discomfort and that one message reasonably communicated to ECPs by the "most moisture," "lowest modulus," and "high oxygen" references in context is one of greater comfort when the INFUSE lenses are worn. Thus, the panel agreed with NAD and concluded that the Bausch + Lomb INFUSE brochure communicates to ECPs the implied message that INFUSE lenses provide greater eye comfort than competitive daily lenses, a message not supported by the record.
The panel recommended, therefore, that Bausch + Lomb modify its advertising to avoid conveying the implied message that the physical properties of its Bausch + Lomb INFUSE lenses ("most moisture," "lowest modulus," and "high oxygen") lead to superior consumer relevant benefits versus competing lenses, including DT1 lenses.
The NARB panel agreed with NAD that the claim that Bausch + Lomb INFUSE "Maintains 96% of its moisture for a full 16 hours – more than the leading silicone hydrogel daily disposable" is not properly supported because the advertiser failed to show that the claimed moisture retention differential is material. Thus, the panel recommended that the claim be discontinued.
Unsurpassed Overall Vision and Comfort Claims and Percentage Agreement Claims
In support of its parity claim, as well as several percentage agreement claims, Bausch + Lomb relied on the results of its 893 Clinical Study. The NARB panel agreed with NAD that the 893 Study did not provide proper support for the advertiser's unsurpassed claim (a comparative establishment claim) because there are methodological deficiencies directly relevant to this analysis, the most important being limiting the enrollment in the study to wearers of standard, not daily, contact lenses.
Therefore, the panel recommended that Bausch discontinue the claim that Bausch + Lomb INFUSE has "unsurpassed overall comfort and vision compared to Dailies Total1."
The NARB panel concluded that Bausch + Lomb's four percentage agreement claims are monadic in nature, and accordingly the substantiation can be evaluated under a less rigorous standard. The panel found that the methodological shortcomings of the 893 Study are not disqualifying, but recommended modifications to the following claims:
"89% of patients agreed Bausch + Lomb INFUSE reduces halos and glare even in low light conditions."
"84% agreed Bausch + Lomb INFUSE reduced irritation and discomfort."
"73% agreed Bausch + Lomb INFUSE helped minimize symptoms of contact lens dryness."
The NARB panel recommended that the 84% claim and the 73% claim either be discontinued or modified to match the language in the survey (e.g., "protect against irritation" rather than "reduced irritation") to which agreement was expressed. Further, the panel recommended that Bausch + Lomb discontinue the 89%, 84%, and 73% claims or disclose the stated percentages of those who indicated that they "slightly agree."
Finally, the NARB panel recommended that Bausch + Lomb discontinue the claim that "95% of patients agreed Bausch + Lomb INFUSE provides clear vision even when driving at night" because the 893 Study did not determine which subjects, if any, drove at night during the study period. The panel concluded that it was not appropriate for the 893 Study to use passenger data as support for a claim about drivers.
In agreement with NAD, the NARB panel recommended that Bausch + Lomb modify the chart in the INFUSE brochure accompanying the claim "Compared to leading silicone hydrogel daily disposables, only Bausch + Lomb INFUSE is designed with aspheric optics to reduce spherical aberration across the entire power range" to indicate that the lens property being compared is "Spherical Aberration Control Across the Entire Power Range."
In its advertiser's statement, Bausch + Lomb stated that it "will comply with NARB's decision." The advertiser further stated that it "appreciates NARB's finding that Bausch+ Lomb's 893 Study supports its monadic percentage agreement claims, as modified according to NARB's decision." Although the advertiser noted that it "respectfully disagrees" with some of NARB's findings which "misstate some of Bausch+ Lomb's positions and arguments," it stated that it "is a strong supporter of the self-regulatory process and will consider NAD's and NARB's recommendations with respect to its advertising going forward."
All BBB National Programs case decision summaries can be found in the case decision library. For the full text of NAD, NARB, and CARU decisions, subscribe to the online archive.
About BBB National Programs: BBB National Programs is where businesses turn to enhance consumer trust and consumers are heard. The non-profit organization creates a fairer playing field for businesses and a better experience for consumers through the development and delivery of effective third-party accountability and dispute resolution programs. Embracing its role as an independent organization since the restructuring of the Council of Better Business Bureaus in June 2019 , BBB National Programs today oversees more than a dozen leading national industry self-regulation programs, and continues to evolve its work and grow its impact by providing business guidance and fostering best practices in arenas such as advertising, child-directed marketing, and privacy. To learn more, visit bbbprograms.org.
About the National Advertising Review Board (NARB): The National Advertising Review Board (NARB) is the appellate body for BBB National Programs' advertising self-regulatory programs. NARB's panel members include 85 distinguished volunteer professionals from the national advertising industry, agencies, and public members, such as academics and former members of the public sector. NARB serves as a layer of independent industry peer review that helps engender trust and compliance in NAD, CARU, and DSSRC matters.
View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/national-advertising-review-board-recommends-bausch--lomb-discontinue-or-modify-certain-claims-for-infuse-contact-lenses-301519446.html
‘No one would have flinched if our meal was just $3 more, but the way it was broken out was just weird and struck us the wrong way.’
Warren Buffett needed just two weeks to put together Berkshire Hathaway Inc's $11.6 billion takeover of Alleghany Corp, its largest acquisition in six years, even as he balked at paying the insurer's banking fee, a regulatory filing on Monday shows. Alleghany said its Chief Executive Officer Joseph Brandon met with Buffett for dinner in New York City on March 7, where after some "casual conversation" Buffett offered $850 per share in cash for the company, less the fee for bankers at Goldman Sachs.
A recent study from the career experts Zety says that 40% of respondents fear retirement more than death. And almost nine in 10 responded that their biggest retirement fear is not having enough income. For married couples, planning retirement for two people can … Continue reading → The post Average Retirement Savings for Married Couples By Age appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
The publicly traded Santa Clara company leased 210,000 square feet of space in Fremont last year. Now its plans for the site are coming into focus.
The magazine praised Cisco's commitment to its employees as they return to work. The company topped last year's list, too.
Starbucks has experienced phenomenal growth and success. Learn more about Starbucks competitors and where the company stands in relation to them.
Elon Musk will no longer join Twitter’s board American owner set to lose billions on Boots sale FTSE 100 falls 0.7pc after February GDP disappoints Oil prices slump amid China lockdowns Lucy Burton: It’s too late for Hong Kong to regain expats’ trust Sign up here for our daily business briefing newsletter
BRUSSELS/LONDON (Reuters) -OPEC told the European Union on Monday that current and future sanctions on Russia could create one of the worst ever oil supply shocks and it would be impossible to replace those volumes, and signalled it would not pump more. European Union officials held talks in Vienna with representatives of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries amid calls for the group to increase output and as the EU considers potential sanctions on Russian oil. "We could potentially see the loss of more than 7 million barrels per day (bpd) of Russian oil and other liquids exports, resulting from current and future sanctions or other voluntary actions," OPEC Secretary General Mohammad Barkindo said, according to a copy of his speech seen by Reuters.
(Reuters) -Oil prices climbed on Tuesday on easing concerns about demand in China after Shanghai relaxed some COVID-19-related restrictions and OPEC warned it would be impossible to increase output enough to offset lost Russian supply. Brent crude futures were up $2.98 or 3.03% to $101.46 a barrel, and U.S. West Texas Intermediate was up $3 or 3.18% to $97.29 a barrel at 0640 GMT. Shanghai said on Monday that more than 7,000 residential units had been classified as lower-risk areas after reporting no new infections for 14 days, and districts have since been announcing which compounds can be opened up.
AMSTERDAM (Reuters) -Just Eat Takeaway.com, Europe's largest online food ordering service, said on Tuesday it will partner with supermarket operator Ahold's flagship Dutch Albert Heijn chain to deliver groceries and convenience products. Financial terms were not disclosed. While a tie up between the country's biggest food delivery service and its biggest grocer had seemed logical, Ahold also operates its own grocery delivery service, as well as e-commerce site Bol.com, which is more popular than Amazon in the Netherlands.
Oil prices have faded, and are now nearly back to where they traded before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The dynamic has had a major impact on stocks, with natural gas producers outperforming companies that produce more oil. In the past month, Exxon Mobil (ticker: XOM) is down 0.7% and ConocoPhillips (COP) has traded flat, while natural gas producer EQT (EQT) is up 45% and Southwestern Energy (SWN) has risen 44%.
Ford Motor Co said on Monday it has signed a preliminary deal to buy lithium from a Lake Resources NL facility in Argentina, marking the first time the automaker has publicly announced where it will procure the electric vehicle battery metal. The deal is a major bet by Ford on direct lithium extraction (DLE), a relatively new breed of technologies that filter the metal from brines and use far less acreage than open-pit mines and evaporation ponds. General Motors Co, BMW, Stellantis NV and other Ford rivals have inked supply deals of their own with companies planning to use DLE technology.
Piper Sandler analyst Ian Macpherson sees large upside for the industry with oil prices expected to remain high.
When looking for the best artificial intelligence stocks to buy, identify companies using AI technology to improve products or gain a strategic edge, such as Google, Microsoft and Nvidia.
(Bloomberg) -- The current tide of antitrust scrutiny and regulations focused on big technology companies has conspicuously omitted one company: Microsoft Corp., the software and cloud-computing behemoth that was the notorious target of a landmark U.S. government lawsuit in the 1990s. Microsoft, the thinking goes, was already humbled by years of intense government oversight, and since it largely caters to other companies, instead of consumers, it doesn’t belong in the same category as Facebook,
Yahoo Finance Live examines trends in PC sales slowing down after two years of consecutive growth and how pandemic and supply chain pressures may be contributing to this.
Tesla CEO Elon Musk lamented the rising cost of lithium—a key material in rechargeable lithium-ion EV batteries—in a recent tweet. He even suggested Tesla might get into the mining business.
(Bloomberg) -- Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has caused one of the biggest upheavals to global petroleum markets in living memory. It still isn’t resulting in a clamor for replacement barrels from west Africa.Most Read from BloombergUkraine Update: Austria Chancellor to Meet Putin; New War FrontCovid Could Be Surging in the U.S. Right Now and We Might Not Even Know ItMusk Rejects Twitter’s Offer to Join Board in Surprise TwistSingapore’s Lee Warns U.S. Against Isolating China Over UkraineUkraine
Setting aside money regularly is one of the surest ways to save for retirement–especially when you take advantage of tax savings over time. Though some retirement accounts are tax-deferred, one popular option that isn't tax-deferred is a Roth IRA. However, … Continue reading → The post How Much to Put in a Roth IRA per Month appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
This might not seem like enough to move significant amounts of product, but in many Southeast Asian markets, social commerce sellers are making up an increasingly large portion of e-commerce. In fact, according to a recent Bain report, social commerce accounted for 65% of Vietnam’s $22 billion online retail economy last year. Despite their combined retailing power, many social commerce sellers cannot buy in bulk directly from brands.