Counterfeit lenses sold by Newcastle woman 'posed health risk' - BBC News

2022-05-14 08:59:50 By : Ms. Jodie Xu

A woman sold counterfeit coloured contact lenses which posed a "public health concern", a jury has heard.

Investigators bought the Freshlook Colorblends from Alluring Lenses - run by Zahra Gillani over Facebook - in 2018, Newcastle Crown Court was told.

Analysis showed each of the three sets was fake. Ms Gillani, 31, denies three counts of selling and one count of possessing counterfeit goods.

The court heard she will argue she believed them to be genuine.

An investigator for TM Eye Ltd, a private firm that targets counterfeit trade, bought three colours of lenses - sterling grey, brilliant blue and gemstone green - in March and April 2018.

Each set cost £15 and they were found to be counterfeit versions of the Novartis AG lenses, the court heard.

On 3 July 2018, a stock check on her website revealed she was offering 496 lenses for sale worth £12,340.

Two days later, the investigators raided her home on Gowland Avenue in Newcastle where they seized a large quantity of lenses as well as Alluring Lenses labels and packaging.

A number of the lenses, which she had bought from China and South Korea, were tested and all were found to be counterfeit, prosecutor Julian Goode said.

"It's important because companies such as [Novartis AG] lose a significant amount of revenue when their items are not sold and counterfeit items are sold in their place," Mr Goode told the court.

"In this case, there is a public health concern as lenses that are counterfeit have not been subjected to the rigorous checks one would expect from genuine products produced by genuine companies."

He said "there is no dispute" the items were counterfeit, but Ms Gillani claimed she sold them believing them to be "genuine and legitimate".

The court heard she declined to comment when interviewed by TM Eye officers except to say: "I've always believed I was selling legitimate products."

Follow BBC North East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to northeastandcumbria@bbc.co.uk.

HM Courts and Tribunals Service

Bogus tradesman who preyed on vulnerable North East women jailed

North East weather: Hour by hour forecast for Saturday as temperatures set to hit 20 °C

Wallsend landscape gardener who fleeced customers out of thousands freed to work in same trade

The best spa facilities in Northumberland

Bulford makes the difference in all-North East final at Wembley

Study shows Newcastle is the second ‘Most British city’ in the UK

Ukraine wins battle for city of Kharkiv – reports

Covid outbreak a great disaster - Kim Jong-un

Dozens die as blaze guts office building in Delhi

Ukraine: The spy war within the war

How Sri Lanka's war heroes became villains

The pupils too afraid to return to school

Millions hit hard as cooking gas prices soar in India

East Africa drought: 'The suffering here has no equal'

How asteroids could provide Earth's future resources

Why an Indian couple is suing their son for grandchild

What Hong Kong can expect from 'Beijing's enforcer'

Can solar resolve Puerto Rico's energy nightmare?

Russia pushed back from Kharkiv - front line report

Correspondent Quentin Sommerville and cameraman Darren Conway are with Ukrainian troops as they advance.

Russia fighting for motherland in Ukraine - Putin

The Russian leader uses Victory Day to tie the war in Ukraine to the fight against Nazi Germany

LISTEN: The extraordinary story of Putin's life

A revealing history as told by those who have watched, studied and worked with the Russian president

© 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.